Good Consequences
What do you mean there are good consequences?
Consequences are a way to measure the weight of our actions in roleplaying games. They are the risks, dilemmas, and opportunities presented by the possibility of success and failure.
A "good consequence" needs a definition, but can it actually be defined? Yes, of course it can, because I'm human and therefore decide the answers to unanswerable questions.
Consequence: (noun) 1. the effect, result, or outcome of something occurring earlier.
Good: (adj.) 1. a thing which is meaningful to the individual(s) involved within the fiction of both the narrative and game.
A good consequence, by my definition, is still way too vague!
Let's Talk Table Talk
We're generally expected and encouraged to run a session zero before starting a campaign with any sort of roleplaying game. It is in these sessions when characters are made, settings are discussed, and safety tools are agreed upon. I propose that we also consider talking about "good consequences" for our roleplaying games during session zeros.
If we can all mutually decide on good consequences, either as individual lists or as a group, then we all know what narrative elements are at risk to us in the campaign.
Example
Riley decides that good consequences for their character's actions include:
- Wounds
- Death
- Putting allies at risk
- Reputation instability
- Loss of mundane items / resources
- Loss of magic item power, but not breaking or destroying them
On the other side of the table, Becky decides that good consequences for their character's actions include:
- Wounds
- Permanent retirement, but not death
- Putting allies in non-deadly danger
- Reputation instability
- Loss of mundane & magical items / resources
We can see how these lists differ, and how knowing them ahead of time allows the GM to present difficult choices for their players.
And,
It's worth noting that in games where players describe the consequences of their actions (either as foreshadowing (see Public Access for an example of this), or literally they get to decide (see some story games)) there isn't much of a need to go over good consequences beforehand, because the player theoretically already understands what a good consequence for them is.
Good consequences might also be determinable through campaign setting. In a game like Mythic Bastionland, tarnishing your reputation is a really potent consequence with genuine narrative ramifications that feel like they have weight. Most players will recognize this and agree.
In OSR games, Death & Dismemberment tables serve an interesting purpose where they present additional consequences for damaging actions beyond death. Broken limbs forcing an early retirement can have just as much narrative weight as death, if not more, depending on who you talk to.
Good consequences don't have to be death. Good consequences can be living with nothing. What's a good consequence for you?
Final Thoughts
Imperceptible motion means no final thoughts today.
Thanks for reading!
Things on my radar:
- The Bloggies have begun! If you want to nominate any of my posts for consideration, I would be so thrilled and thankful (anyone can nominate any amount of blog posts from anyone). My personal favorite posts that I wrote this year have been the recent Consequences, Machines, Poke, Prod, Pull, Show You Care, and the less recent Two Rival Factions and Want-Have-Sacrifice. Oh, and also this post that you're reading now!
- Blogposts I nominated today:
- Distancing yourself from GM-centrism, one step at a time - anb
- Beyond the hex - Odinson
- A Sicko's Guide to Prepping D&D - Valeria Loves
- What players want to know: 21 needed answers for session 1 - Rise Up Comus
- Blogposts I nominated today:
- Nonogueram is a fun procedural Picross meets Slay the Spire game.
- Max at TwoWeirdStudio uses Tension Trees to prepare for a session. These are quite similar to the Lazy GM's Steps that I use, and had me thinking about what to absorb into my own notes.
- Habeeb has a new axis essay about politics. I think this is the least boring political worldbuilding/game design post I've read so far.